Neutrogena vs Cetaphil: Which Facial Cleanser Should You Buy?

A medicated acne wash against a fragrance-free gentle cleanser: which suits your skin, from what the listings state?

Updated 1 min read
On this page 5 sections
  1. Quick verdict
  2. Head-to-head summary
  3. Criterion by criterion
  4. Evidence and limits
  5. Want more choices?


WellnessPicks is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this page we may earn a commission from Shopee, Lazada or TikTok Shop, at no extra cost to you. No brand pays to be featured or ranked. How we make money.


Neutrogena Deep Clean Acne Foaming Cleanser 100 g (Kenvue Official Store)

Best for acne-prone and oily skin

Neutrogena Deep Clean Acne Foaming Cleanser 100 g (Kenvue Official Store)

87/100

4.4

โ‚ฑ314 per 100 g

Shopee

Cetaphil Gentle Skin Cleanser 236 ml, for sensitive skin (Cetaphil Flagship Store)

Best for sensitive, dry skin

Cetaphil Gentle Skin Cleanser 236 ml, for sensitive skin (Cetaphil Flagship Store)

82/100

4.1

โ‚ฑ565 ~โ‚ฑ239 per 100 ml

Shopee

Quick verdict

Overall pick Neutrogena Deep Clean Acne Foaming Cleanser 100 g (Kenvue Official Store)

Neutrogena scores higher overall (87 vs 82): it has an exact FDA notification, a full ingredient list and a mild 0.5% salicylic acid wash for acne-prone skin. Cetaphil is the shorter, fragrance-free option the guide picks for sensitive, dry skin, but its listing has wrong volume and model fields.

Choose Neutrogena if

You have acne-prone or oily skin and want a mild medicated wash (0.5% salicylic acid) with a full ingredient list. It contains fragrance and can dry or sting skin that is already irritated.

Choose Cetaphil if

Your skin is dry or sensitive and you want a short, fragrance-free ingredient list from the brand's flagship store. It is not an acne treatment.

The overall pick follows the weighted Wellness Picks score (87 vs 82 out of 100), not the number of criteria won below.

Head-to-head summary

87 / 100
Wellness Picks score
82 / 100
Best for acne-prone and oily skin
Best for
Best for sensitive, dry skin
โ‚ฑ314 (โ‚ฑ314 per 100 g)
Price checked
โ‚ฑ565 (~โ‚ฑ239 per 100 ml)
Exact FDA notification and a full ingredient list
Key strength
Exact FDA notification, short fragrance-free ingredient list
Contains fragrance and a medicated ingredient; not for already irritated or eczema-prone skin
Key limitation
Volume and model fields in the specifications are wrong
A notified "Neutrogena Deep Clean Acne Foaming Cleanser" exists (JNTL Consumer Health), NN-1000014716750, valid to June 2028, and a later notification NN-1000016758794. The FDA notifies cosmetics; it does not approve them. The advisories we found for the brand name other Neutrogena products (a water cream, an intense-repair product and 2021 aerosol sunscreens), not this cleanser
FDA status
A notified "Cetaphil Gentle Skin Cleanser" exists (Galderma Philippines), for example NN-1000013792957, valid to November 2027, with several other notifications for the same name. The FDA notifies cosmetics; it does not approve them. No FDA advisory found for the brand
No
Registration number in listing?
No
Printed in full: water, glycerin, sodium cocoyl glycinate, sodium cocoyl isethionate, cocamidopropyl betaine, salicylic acid, phenoxyethanol, fragrance, o-cymen-5-ol and others
Ingredients
Printed in full: aqua, glycerin, cetearyl alcohol, panthenol, niacinamide, pantolactone, xanthan gum, sodium cocoyl isethionate, sodium benzoate, citric acid
"Removes 99% dirt, including acne-causing bacteria", 0.5% salicylic acid with IPMP (o-cymen-5-ol), "skin pH friendly", "dermatologist tested", non-comedogenic
Claims
"Clinically proven", "hypoallergenic", "dermatologist tested", fragrance-free, paraben-free, non-comedogenic, "defends against the five signs of skin sensitivity"
Skin type is ticked for acne-prone, combination, dry, normal and oily at once
Inconsistencies
The specification sheet says volume 250 ml and model "1 l" for a 236 ml bottle; skin-care benefits list "dullness" for a cleanser sold for sensitivity
Kenvue Official Store: 9 years on Shopee, 2M ratings, 1.1M followers, 100% response; 4.9 stars from 10K+ ratings on this listing, 10K+ sold
Seller
Cetaphil Flagship Store: 7 years on Shopee, 866.5K ratings, 970.5K followers, 100% response; 4.9 stars from 10K+ ratings on this listing
Check price

Rows come from each product’s record and from the guide that ranks both. Prices checked 2026-10-14. We did not use or test either product.

Criterion by criterion

Where the evidence is not strong enough to call a winner, we say so.

What you will care about when choosing

?
Price per 100 (different units)Not enough evidence
?

Neutrogena is priced per 100 g (โ‚ฑ314 for 100 g) and Cetaphil per ml (โ‚ฑ565 for 236 ml, about โ‚ฑ239 per 100 ml). One is grams and one is millilitres, so we do not call this one.

Evidence: Shopee prices in our facial cleanser guide.

Fragrance-free
WINS

Cetaphil is described as fragrance-free; the Neutrogena ingredient list includes fragrance.

Evidence: Both ingredient lists as printed in the Shopee listings.

WINS
Medicated acne ingredient in the formula

Neutrogena lists 0.5% salicylic acid; Cetaphil lists none and is not sold as an acne product.

Evidence: Both Shopee listings.

TIE
Full ingredient list printedTie
TIE

Both listings print the full list.

Evidence: Both Shopee listings.

From our weighted scoring

23TIE
Provenance and registration25 ptsTie
24TIE

23 vs 24 out of 25 points.

17TIE
Listing disclosure20 ptsTie
16TIE

17 vs 16 out of 20 points.

15TIE
Claims honesty20 ptsTie
14TIE

15 vs 14 out of 20 points.

7WINS
Consistency10 pts
6

7 vs 6 out of 10 points.

15TIE
Seller record15 ptsTie
15TIE

15 vs 15 out of 15 points.

10WINS
Value10 pts
7

10 vs 7 out of 10 points.

Final result

Neutrogena3rounds won
VS
Cetaphil1rounds won

Ties: 5  ยท  Not enough evidence to call: 1

๐Ÿ† Wellness Picks pickNeutrogenaWeighted score 87 vs 82 out of 100

Rounds count every row equally. The weighted Wellness Picks score does not, and it decides the pick. On the scoring axes, a lead of at least 10% of the axis points counts as a round won.

Evidence and limits

  • Neutrogena: listing checked 2026-10-14; registration NN-1000014716750.
  • Cetaphil: listing checked 2026-10-14; registration NN-1000013792957.
  • We compare what each listing and the FDA notification list state; we did not use or test either product, and the FDA notifies cosmetics, it does not approve them.
  • Not compared for lack of evidence: how well either cleans or how it affects your skin, and warranty or returns.
  • Neutrogena: notification NN-1000014716750, valid to June 2028. Cetaphil: NN-1000013792957, valid to November 2027, with several other notifications for the same name. No FDA advisory found naming either cleanser.
  • The Neutrogena listing ticks acne-prone, combination, dry, normal and oily skin at once. The Cetaphil listing gives volume 250 ml and model "1 l" for a 236 ml bottle.
  • "Dermatologist tested", "clinically proven" and "hypoallergenic" are the brands' own words; neither listing includes a study. A medicated wash does not replace treatment for moderate or severe acne.
  • Prices change; a price change does not change a score unless we re-score the product. This is general information, not medical advice.
  • Fact-checked and reviewed by WellnessPicks team on 2026-10-25.

Want more choices?

How we score

  • FDA number looked up on the official record
  • Listing read line by line, label included
  • No brand pays to be ranked

Full method โ†’